Billy Napier sits squarely on the hot seat at Florida – there’s no more room for error.
Matt Zemek, 16powers.com.
We have arrived at the point of no return for Florida football head coach Billy Napier. It’s true that even the most visible and prominent college football programs should generally not fire their coaches after only two seasons, but with the College Football Playoff expanding to 12 teams this year, the consequences of not having a good college football team are more severe than ever before. In the four-team playoff era, the awareness that the playoff belonged to a very small group of teams made it easier for coaches to ask for patience. If a program wasn’t ready to contend for top-four status, everyone – fans, journalists, administrators, and the players themselves – could understand why. With 12 teams now in the playoff, however, that line of thought won’t fly. Programs with a strong football brand and identity should at least come close to the 12-team playoff on a consistent basis, even if they don’t actually make it.
Billy Napier has to give Florida fans and his bosses in the athletic department enough evidence to show that the Gators can knock on the door of the playoff. No one is expecting Florida to actually get there in 2024, but Napier and the Gators have to improve enough this season that a 2025 leap to playoff contention is seen as realistic, based on a thorough analysis and evaluation of the program.
Right now, before the 2024 season begins, Florida isn’t remotely close to being a playoff contender. The gap between UF’s current position and a standard of playoff contention is as wide as the Grand Canyon. This is a final chance for Napier to change the direction of the program in a positive direction, a final shot at convincing everyone in Gainesville that he can build an elite winner.
The reason Dan Mullen was pushed out at Florida was that he couldn’t recruit. Mullen’s X-and-O chops were elite. He was a brilliant play designer. However, he just couldn’t bring in next-level talent to the program. When Napier was hired, a clear and central expectation for him was that he would recruit so brilliantly that Florida’s talent gap relative to the competition in the SEC would be wiped away.
That has not happened.
What makes everything worse for Napier and Florida is that without elite talent, the coaching has needed to be on point in order to minimize the Gators’ on-field deficiencies. Yet, watching Gator games under Napier has been a study in frustration because the staff has not put players in position to do their jobs. Fundamental breakdowns have been far too frequent for this team. Even in the games when Florida played well in 2023, something bad would happen – a horrific mistake at the worst possible time – would undo the good work Napier and his staff did. A prime example of this is the 4th and 17 conversion Missouri made against Florida, en route to a game-winning score against the Gators. UF was on the verge of pulling off a huge upset of a team which eventually finished the season in the top 10, but a coverage breakdown on 4th and 17 ruined the Gators’ plans. The combination of mistakes and inadequate recruiting has put Napier firmly and centrally on the hot seat in Gainesville. There is zero question that if Florida doesn’t win at least seven games this season, Napier will be gone. In all likelihood, Florida will probably need to win eight games for Napier to be retained. He has coached his way into a corner, and now he has to wiggle out of trouble. It won’t be easy, and moreover, it is reasonable to wonder if the Gators have the horses needed to reach the next level as a program.
Graham Mertz did not have a bad season last year. He actually did play better than he had at Wisconsin, where his underperforming ways caused two coaches – regular coach Paul Chryst and interim coach Jim Leonhard – to not be retained by the Badgers. Mertz looked genuinely good at times during the 2023 SEC season. To that extent, Napier and his staff did not do a bad job of developing him. Yet, even if you acknowledge that Graham Mertz was not a failure at Florida in 2023, it remains that his ceiling might not be all that high. He might be the kind of quarterback who, even when he is doing most things well, is not a supreme difference-maker for a team. Many would still say that UF needs a higher-end quarterback if it wants to get better results. We will see in 2024 if Graham Mertz gets yet another coach fired, or if Billy Napier and his quarterback can make their marriage work.
We said above that Florida probably needs to win eight games for Napier to be retained. Does the 2024 schedule offer a decent chance for that scenario to unfold? It won’t be easy.
The Gators host Miami in a Week 1 hot seat special featuring Mario Cristobal, another coach whose fan base has run out of patience for him. If Florida can get by that game, the Gators then host Texas A&M, led by first-year coach Mike Elko. You won’t find a single college football analyst who thinks Napier is a better coach than Elko. Florida will have a hard time winning that game, even at home.
The October road trip to Tennessee will be rough. The home game against Kentucky one week later is a must-win if Napier is to win at least eight games this year. Then comes the month which will firmly and finally prove if Billy Napier has a future at Florida. November of 2024 is a death-march schedule for the Gators.
It would be bad enough for Napier if he had to face Georgia, Texas, LSU, Ole Miss, and Florida State at any point in a season. In November of this year, the Gators play all five of those teams in consecutive weeks. Will Billy Napier coach at Florida in 2025? Based on this schedule, there’s little chance of that happening.
Napier will simply have to coach so well that Florida defies the odds and exceeds all expectations. Let’s see if a coach, with his back to the wall, can do something no one is anticipating in Gainesville.
Be the first to comment